Menu

Services

Payroll ProcessingHR & ComplianceTime & AttendanceBackground Checks401(k) PlansHealth BenefitsColorado Compliance
Pricing

About Us

Your Payroll PartnerOur Payroll PlatformReviewsThe Unify FamilyCareers

Resources

Client CenterFAQBlogPayroll FormsState Tax RegistrationColorado Agency AccessTraining Resources

Contact

Customer SupportGet Started
970.232.1284
A parent and child standing in a mountain meadow at sunrise
New: health benefits with Grove Benefit Advisors

Health benefits, sorted out locally.

Group plans, ICHRAs, individual coverage, and pre-tax premiums. Unify Payroll and Grove Benefit Advisors are both right here in Fort Collins, and the payroll side gets done right.

Pay premiums with full-value dollars

With a Section 125 plan, employees' share of a group health premium comes out before tax. Same coverage, bigger paycheck, and lower payroll tax for you.

$100 of pay set aside for a group health premium
After tax it buys $75.95 of coverage. Pre-tax it buys $100.00.
Paid from your paycheck after tax76¢ on the dollar
Paid pre-tax through a Section 125 plan100¢ on the dollar
Federal income tax
12%
Social Security + Medicare
7.65%
Colorado income tax
4.4%
$96/mo
more take-home for an employee paying a $400 monthly premium
$31/mo
less employer payroll tax on that same premium (the 7.65% FICA match)

Illustration for a household in the 12% federal bracket, which covers a Larimer County family at the median household income ($93,276, U.S. Census ACS 2024). Colorado rate 4.4% (2026). Your rates may differ. Applies to employer group plans. Individual-market premiums can't go through a Section 125 plan, except off-exchange plans paired with an ICHRA.

How we set it up

1

Put the plan in writing

A Section 125 premium-only plan needs a short written plan document. We'll make sure one is in place before deductions start.

2

Set up the deductions

We set each deduction up pre-tax in payroll, so it skips federal, Social Security, Medicare, and Colorado tax and lands right on the W-2.

3

Keep it in sync

Open enrollment and life changes flow to the next paycheck. Grove handles the carrier side; we handle payroll.

Where payroll setups usually go wrong
  • Owners enrolled in the Section 125 plan. S corporation owners (over 2%), partners, and sole proprietors can't be.
  • S corporation owner premiums left off the W-2. They belong in income-tax wages, but not Social Security or Medicare wages.
  • Individual-market premiums reimbursed outside an ICHRA or QSEHRA. That can cost $100 per employee per day in federal excise tax.

Is a group plan even the right fit?

More owners are asking about ICHRAs. Here's how the three paths compare at a glance.

Small-group plan
The traditional route
  • You control the cost
    The carrier sets the renewal
  • Employees choose their plan
    From the options you pick
  • Tax-free to employees
    Pre-tax through Section 125
  • Light on admin
    Enrollment, renewals, participation rules
  • Premium tax credits stay possible
    Only if the plan is unaffordable
ICHRA
Now also called a CHOICE arrangement
  • You control the cost
    You set the allowance
  • Employees choose their plan
    Any individual plan
  • Tax-free to employees
    Reimbursements are tax-free
  • Light on admin
    Notices, proof of coverage, reimbursements
  • Premium tax credits stay possible
    If declined and unaffordable
A raise + individual plans
Simplest to run
  • You control the cost
    You set the amount
  • Employees choose their plan
    Any plan, or none
  • Tax-free to employees
    Taxed like any wages
  • Light on admin
    Just payroll
  • Premium tax credits stay possible
    Based on household income

Meet our partner, Grove Benefit Advisors

Grove is a licensed, independent insurance agency in Fort Collins and a certified broker for Connect for Health Colorado. Their advisors give straight answers in plain language and stay with you after the sale.

Buying your own coverage? Grove also runs ColoradoHealthInsurance.com, where you can compare individual and family plans with real prices and book help at no cost.

Why not just use a national payroll company's insurance desk?

Rates are the same through any broker. The difference is who picks up the phone, and whether the payroll side is right.

Who you talk to

National payroll + insurance deskA national sales line
Unify Payroll + GroveLocal advisors in Fort Collins

Payroll required

National payroll + insurance deskOften must run payroll with them
Unify Payroll + GroveGrove works with any payroll

Advice on options

National payroll + insurance deskSteered to their own platform
Unify Payroll + GroveGroup, ICHRA, or individual: whatever fits

Pre-tax deductions

National payroll + insurance deskSynced by software, support by ticket
Unify Payroll + GroveSet up and checked by people you know

Common questions

Insurance is offered through Grove Benefit Advisors LLC, a licensed Colorado insurance agency (Colorado agency license 958957). Unify Payroll does not sell insurance. Tax figures are general information, not tax advice.

Let's find the right fit for your team

Book a short call, or send a question first. You'll hear from a real person here in Fort Collins, and we'll bring Grove in when it's time to look at plans.